Why One Country Song Can Be No. 1 and No. 3 in the Same Week

In late summer 2024, one country single held two different peak positions at the same time. Drew Baldridge’s “She’s Somebody’s Daughter” reached No. 1 on the Country Aircheck/Mediabase chart. On Billboard’s Country Airplay chart, the same record peaked at No. 3.

Neither figure is a misprint, and neither chart made an error. The two were tracking the same radio weeks, and since a change in late 2022 they have drawn on the same monitoring data. They still produced different answers, and the reason is worth knowing if you have ever read a press release and wondered what its number meant.

One song, two peak positions

Baldridge’s Country Airplay chart history lists the song’s peak as No. 3. The Mediabase result comes from the announcement around the record, reported by All Country News on August 27, 2024, which named the chart as Country Aircheck/Mediabase and the position as No. 1.

That announcement carried two further claims: that the song set a record high for a self-released artist, passing a mark set by Aaron Watson in 2017, and that it was the first self-released song to reach the Top 5 in the chart’s 34 year history. The publication attributed both to the press release rather than to the chart companies, and we repeat them on that basis rather than as confirmed facts. Which is the practical point: a release that says “No. 1” is usually telling the truth about one specific chart, and not always the one a reader pictures.

Same ingredients, different recipes

The surprising part is that the two charts are no longer built from rival monitoring systems. Inside Radio reported on November 15, 2022 that Luminate had retired BDS, its own radio tracking service, and partnered with Mediabase for airplay monitoring, effective with charts dated November 12, 2022. Billboard described itself as using Mediabase monitoring supplied through Luminate, its data partner, which made Mediabase the single source of the underlying data.

What stayed different is the arithmetic applied to it. Billboard ranks Country Airplay records by audience impressions, an estimate of how many listeners had the chance to hear a play. Mediabase builds a points total that weights each spin according to the station that aired it. In the same Inside Radio piece, Philippe Generali, the RCS president and chief executive who has overseen Mediabase since 2010, described the two charts as pies made from the same ingredients by “different bakers with different recipes.”

Two smaller differences add up as well. The chart weeks do not line up, with Billboard’s running Monday through Sunday and Mediabase’s Sunday through Saturday, so a song added mid week can land in different weeks on each. The rules for retiring an aging single also differ, which changes how long a record stays eligible to climb. Billboard’s published chart legend, quoted in that article, notes that a play at 4 a.m. counts for less than one at 4 p.m.

How often the two charts actually disagree

Disagreement is the exception. Across the first 45 weeks of 2022, Inside Radio reported, the two charts named the same No. 1 on 35 occasions. Over that same stretch Country Airplay produced 28 different No. 1 singles and Mediabase produced 33, a gap that reflects how quickly each chart turns its top spot over. Its worked example was Cole Swindell’s “She Had Me at Heads Carolina,” which spent three weeks at No. 1 on Country Airplay while sitting at No. 2 on Mediabase.

Read that way, the Baldridge split looks less like a contradiction than like an ordinary consequence of two scoring systems meeting a record whose support sat unevenly across the panel. One caution: we do not have station level data for that song, so this is our reading of a known pattern rather than a demonstrated explanation for this case.

Where the Platinum certification fits

Certifications are a separate system again, and they move on their own clock. The RIAA’s searchable Gold and Platinum database lists “She’s Somebody’s Daughter” by Drew Baldridge as a 1X Platinum single, credited to Lyric Ridge Records, with a certification date of December 12, 2025. Coverage published in 2024 describes the song as Gold, which is what it was at the time, so an older article is not wrong so much as frozen. We looked at this certification in more detail in our earlier Sunset Stage Series profile of Baldridge.

The label line is worth a second look. In October 2024, MusicRow reported that Baldridge had begun a partnership with BBR Music Group and BMG Nashville, who would support his single at country radio, and that “Tough People” was released through Stoney Creek Records. The Platinum single, though, is credited to Lyric Ridge Records, the imprint Baldridge founded. Calling him simply independent, or simply signed, each leaves something out.

What we could not confirm

Published accounts of how many stations sit on each reporting panel disagree with each other, and the figures we found are several years old, so we have left the counts out rather than print a number we cannot stand behind. We did not obtain a current methodology document from either company. And we did not review a station level panel list for the Orlando market, so nothing above is a claim about which Central Florida stations report to either chart.

The case for keeping both charts

It is tempting to ask which chart is the real one, and the better answer is that the question is poorly framed. They are measuring different things. Audience impressions approximate how many people were given the chance to hear a song. Weighted spins approximate how hard the format itself is working a record. A team may reasonably care more about one than the other depending on whether the goal is reach or radio commitment.

Our Perspective

We should say plainly that Drew Baldridge is on the Sunset Country Fest 2027 bill, so we have a commercial interest in how his record is described. That is why the numbers above are tied to the RIAA database and to dated published reporting, and why the press-release claims are labeled as such rather than tidied into the story.

Frequently Asked: When a country song is called No. 1, which chart does that mean?

It depends entirely on which chart is named, so look for the name. Billboard’s Country Airplay and the Country Aircheck/Mediabase chart both rank country radio and both now use Mediabase monitoring data, but they rank by different measures over slightly different weeks, so they can place the same song differently. A release that says “No. 1” without naming a chart has not given you enough to go on. Baldridge’s single is the clean example: No. 1 on one, No. 3 on the other, in the same season, with a Platinum certification that arrived more than a year later. The full bill and ticket details are on our tickets page, and common questions are answered in our FAQs.

Sunset Country Fest takes place on April 3, 2027, at the Apopka Amphitheater, 3710 Jason Dwelley Pkwy, Apopka, FL 32712. Gates open at 2:00 PM.

Be First to Know When the Lineup Drops

Join the Sunset Country Fest insider list. Lineup announcements, ticket pre-sales, and festival news straight to your inbox.

Sources & References

Do Billboard Country Airplay and the Mediabase country chart use the same data?

Since charts dated November 12, 2022 both have used Mediabase radio monitoring, after Luminate retired its BDS service and partnered with Mediabase, as Inside Radio reported. They still rank songs differently because Billboard ranks by audience impressions while Mediabase ranks by weighted spin points.

What did “She’s Somebody’s Daughter” actually peak at?

Billboard’s Country Airplay chart history lists a peak of No. 3. The announcement around the record, reported by All Country News in August 2024, gave it as No. 1 on the Country Aircheck/Mediabase chart. Both figures can be accurate because they describe different charts.

Is the song certified Gold or Platinum?

The RIAA’s Gold and Platinum database lists it as a 1X Platinum single, credited to Lyric Ridge Records, certified on December 12, 2025. Articles from 2024 call it Gold, which was accurate when they were published.

Disclaimer: Important Notice

The information published in this article is based on publicly available data from official sources, press releases, and music industry publications available at the time of writing. Tour dates, ticket prices, venue details, setlists, album release schedules, award nominations, lineup announcements, and all other details referenced in this article are subject to change at any time without prior notice.

Sunset Country Fest makes no representations or warranties, express or implied, regarding the accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of any information contained herein. All changes, cancellations, rescheduling, postponements, or modifications to any events, releases, tour dates, award results, or announcements referenced in this article are the sole responsibility of the artists, record labels, talent agencies, concert promoters, venues, and any other third parties involved.

Sunset Country Fest shall not be held liable for any decisions, travel arrangements, ticket purchases, or other actions taken by readers based on the information published here. We strongly encourage all readers to verify current details, including dates, venues, ticket availability, and event status, directly through official artist channels, venue box offices, and authorized ticketing platforms before making any plans or purchases.

Last updated: November 20, 2026 · Sunset Country Fest Editorial Team · Contact Us